Skip to content

Manual Actions and Reconsideration Requests, Explained

How to confirm a link-related manual action, fix the underlying problem, and write a reconsideration request that holds up.

A manual action is a human reviewer’s decision that a site violates guidelines, applied on top of (and separately from) algorithmic ranking. Link-related manual actions typically cite “unnatural links to your site” or “unnatural links from your site,” and they show up in Search Console rather than as a silent ranking change. Confirming one, fixing it properly, and requesting reconsideration is a specific process, not a guess-and-hope exercise.

In this guide: Manual Actions and Reconsideration Requests, Explained

Confirming it’s actually a manual action

Check the Manual Actions report in Search Console directly. A ranking drop alone is not evidence of a manual action — it’s far more often an algorithm update or a devaluation, covered in https://successtoroad.com/blog/algorithmic-devaluation-vs-penalties/. Don’t start a disavow-and-cleanup project based on assumption; confirm the notice exists first.

What the notice tells you

  • Whether it’s site-wide or affects specific pages/sections
  • Whether it targets links pointing to you or links you’re sending out
  • Sometimes example URLs, though rarely a complete list

Treat the examples as a sample of the pattern, not the full extent of the problem. Run a complete https://successtoroad.com/blog/backlink-audit-guide/ rather than fixing only the URLs mentioned.

Fixing the underlying problem

If the action targets What to do
Links pointing to your site Identify the manipulative pattern, request removals, then apply https://successtoroad.com/blog/disavow-when-and-when-not/ for what can’t be removed
Links you’re sending out Remove or nofollow the paid/exchanged links your own site created

Writing the reconsideration request

A strong request is specific and shows work, not just a promise to do better. Include: what you found during the audit, what you removed versus disavowed and why, evidence of removal outreach (dates, contacts, responses), and a brief statement of process changes if the links were something your own team built. Vague requests (“we’ve cleaned up our links”) without specifics are routinely rejected.

Common mistakes that delay reversal

  • Disavowing everything unfamiliar instead of the actual pattern cited
  • Submitting a reconsideration request before removal outreach has had time to work
  • Resubmitting an unchanged request after a rejection, hoping for a different reviewer
  • Not addressing every category of link mentioned in the original notice

Timeline expectations

Reviews typically take a few weeks, sometimes longer for larger sites. Multiple rejected requests usually mean the underlying pattern wasn’t actually fixed, not that the reviewer missed something — go back to the audit and look for what was left out, particularly around https://successtoroad.com/blog/link-network-and-pbn-detection/ patterns that are easy to miss on a first pass.

Life after the action is lifted

Lifting a manual action doesn’t restore lost rankings automatically or immediately — recovery is gradual as the site is recrawled and re-evaluated. Keep monitoring with a regular cadence afterward; see https://successtoroad.com/blog/how-often-to-audit-backlinks/ for a schedule suited to a site with penalty history.

Preparing the team for the wait

One of the harder parts of handling a manual action isn’t the technical work, it’s managing expectations while waiting for review. Stakeholders often assume a fix should produce an immediate bounce-back in traffic, and when that doesn’t happen right away they assume the fix failed. Set expectations early: lifting the action removes the active suppression, but recovering rankings still depends on the normal crawling and re-evaluation cycle, and some of the traffic decline during the penalty period may reflect factors — competitor movement, seasonal shifts — that a lifted action doesn’t automatically reverse.

Keeping a paper trail throughout

Save every piece of correspondence related to removal requests, every version of the disavow file you submit, and the exact text of your reconsideration request. If a first request is rejected, having this record makes it far easier to identify what was missed rather than guessing, and it protects you if the situation ever needs to be explained to a client or a new team member well after the fact.

Who should be involved internally

A link-related manual action is rarely a purely technical SEO problem to solve alone — it often benefits from input from whoever handled past link-building activity, since they may know exactly which campaigns or vendors produced the pattern being cited. Loop them in early rather than trying to reverse-engineer the cause purely from the audit data, since firsthand knowledge of what was actually done can save significant investigation time.

What happens if a second request is also rejected

A second rejection usually means either the underlying pattern wasn’t fully addressed, or the reconsideration request itself didn’t clearly demonstrate the work that was done. Before submitting a third attempt, go back to basics: re-read the original notice carefully for anything you may have only partially addressed, expand the audit to cover link categories you may have under-scoped the first time, and make the request itself more specific about dates, actions, and evidence rather than repeating the same general language.

Where to go next

Once you’re rebuilding, source replacement placements carefully through https://successtoroad.com/marketplace/, checking traffic and outbound link patterns per https://successtoroad.com/blog/risk-scoring-a-placement-before-you-buy/ so you don’t reintroduce the same problem.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if I have a manual action?

Check the Manual Actions report inside Search Console — it lists any active actions with a brief description. A ranking or traffic drop by itself doesn't confirm one; you need to see the actual notice.

Do I need to disavow before requesting reconsideration?

For a links-to-your-site action, yes — reviewers expect evidence you attempted removal first and disavowed what you couldn't remove. Skipping straight to a request without addressing the links usually results in rejection.

How many times can I submit a reconsideration request?

There's no fixed limit, but resubmitting without meaningfully changing anything rarely works. Each rejection should prompt another look at what the notice actually cited before trying again.

Will my rankings come back immediately after the action is lifted?

Not immediately. Recovery tends to be gradual as pages are recrawled and re-evaluated, and some of the ranking loss may reflect factors beyond the manual action itself.

Put it into practice

Filter 54,483 websites by DR, traffic, niche and price, and order with escrow — you pay only after the link is live.

Browse the marketplace

Keep reading

WhatsApp